http://lparchive.org/Stalin-vs-Martians/
Most of the games listed here aren't bad. Diablo 3 and the Mass Effect series were both good solid games that people like to obsess over thanks to their own expectations not being met. All games have problems if you nit pick enough but actual bad games don't need to be nit picked to find the problems.
My friend has a rule for determining if a game is good or not. If the time he spends in the game is greater than the amount of time he would have gotten for spending the same amount of money going to the movies, it's a good game.